Amidst the intense battle for the Dennis Osadebey Edo State Government House between the People’s Democratic Party and the All Progressives Congress, the recently reinstated Deputy Governor, Philip Shaibu’s defection to the APC, where he has joined forces with his former boss, Senator Adams Oshiomhole sparks speculation that this move may weaken the PDP’s camp.
However, the PDP has dismissed this speculation, maintaining that Shaibu’s defection has neither impact nor implications on the party’s chances of winning the September 21, 2024 governorship election.
While the ruling PDP downplayed the deputy governor’s defection, some APC members, who recognize his potential as an intimidating force, were jubilant, believing that with his being on board, the party would have a clear advantage in securing the government seat in the forthcoming election.
In the meantime, within the APC, the returnee deputy governor faces an acceptability issue. A thorough examination of the situation reveals that his defection has generated intra party mixed reactions.
Before Shaibu’s defection, specifically in April this year, members of the APC in Etsako West Local Government Area of Edo State kicked against his return. The party faithful from his zone roundly rejected any attempt for him to return, saying there is no vacancy for him in the party.
The 12 ward chairmen took their protest to the party secretariat, where they submitted a petition against what they termed the surreptitious moves by Shaibu to return to the party he abandoned in 2020.
“Although opinions are divided among party members and observers about the gale of defections and internal crisis in the Edo PDP, many people are surprised that the PDP has not been able to put its house in order since after the primary election”
In a joint communiqué signed by the 12 ward chairmen in the council, the party members vowed to resist his admittance into the party following his impeachment.
The leader of the delegation, Yakubu Musa presented the communiqué on behalf of the APC stakeholders in the LGA.
He stated that Shaibu’s exit from the APC in 2020 brought peace and tranquility to the party, noting that the former deputy governor’s return would bring rancour and disunity to the party.
On Saturday, July 20, 2024, Shaibu returned to the APC during the launch of the governorship campaign for the September 21 election in Edo State by the party’s National Campaign Council in Benin.
Shaibu, who returned to the APC alongside prominent members of the Dan Orbih-led Legacy Group of the PDP that also defected to the party, boasted that he was back not only to add value to the party, but also to take back the state from PDP.
“On behalf of the Legacy Group, I announce our movement to the APC. We have come to add value to the party. It is time to take back our state. We will not talk too much because action will speak for us. We are not afraid. We are ready to move forward. We, the homeboys, are ready to take our state back through the APC governorship candidate, Monday Okpebholo, and his running mate, Dennis Idahosa. We are not troublemakers, but if it comes, we will use it to rub our body, and we move on,” he had said during the flag off ceremony.
Reacting to his defection, the PDP in a statement by its spokesman, Debo Ologunagba, declared that with his return to the APC, Shaibu has irredeemably sunk deeper into the abyss of rejection; having at last shown his true colours as belonging to the corrupt, malevolent and oppressive political platform that relishes in violence, subverting the will of the people and inflicting pains on Nigerians.
The PDP said that by confessing that his heart has always been with the APC and returning to the party, which is embroiled in a crisis due to an unqualified candidate, Shaibu has validated the widespread opinion that his intention in the governorship race was not to serve the interests and wellbeing of the Edo State people.
“Nigerians now know why Comrade Shaibu had no tangible campaign manifesto, programme or plan for Edo State but only engaged in actions and utterances aimed to derail the PDP governorship nomination processes and frustrate the will of the majority of the people of Edo State.
“Our party has only but pity for Comrade Shaibu for apparently being used and dumped and now on a journey to nowhere as he is currently facing a stiff rejection in the APC where he has been reportedly described as ‘a complete political liability and highly cancerous politician that must be avoided in order to prevent him from infesting our party (APC) with his ill-fated inordinate, desperate and obnoxious ambition.
“APC stakeholders from his Etsako West Local Government Area, reportedly stated that ‘a close assessment of Philip Shaibu’s political participation would reveal him as a man that is politically rancorous and he derives joy in initiating, propagating and sustaining unending crisis in any association or political party he belongs.
“They also described him as having no electoral value and insisted that his return to the APC is a calculated attempt by him ‘to bring rancour, disharmony and unprecedented crisis into the All Progressives Congress. What a damning verdict from home?”
With the verdict by his people, PDP said that his defection will not impact the PDP’s chances in the September 21 off-cycle governorship election.
The party also said that this explained why within 24 hours of his return to the APC, the PDP governorship campaign has swelled as more citizens of Edo State, who do not want to be in the same political platform with Shaibu are now massively declaring support for the PDP and its candidate, Asue Ighodalo.
One thing that worries political Observers and analysts in the calculations of the forthcoming Edo State off-cycle governorship election is the non-mention of the Labour Party and its governorship candidate, Olumide Akpata.
The former President of the Nigerian Bar Association has fought battles within the party to remain the candidate for the forthcoming election but whether the squabbles in the party is affecting his chances of taking over at the Dennis Osadebey House is what observers are yet to figure out.
The Party’s National Publicity Secretary, Obiorah Ufoh has insisted that the Labour Party candidate is a candidate to beat.
He said the party has the best people oriented candidate and with the massive support LP is enjoying in the state, Akpata will cruise home in style on September 21.
In recent weeks, the three major political parties have set up their campaign teams and many people have now shifted attention to the governorship candidates to hear their agenda for the state ahead of the election slated for September 21, 2024.
But within the three major political parties, the last few weeks have been full of intrigues and drama, with political actors aligning and realigning their forces in line with their interest.
But peace appears elusive and seems not to have returned to the camp of the PDP in the state with the internal division within the party which started before the primary election deepening in recent weeks.
The Edo PDP crisis emanated from the disagreement between Governor Obaseki and Shaibu.
The cordial relationship between Governor Obaseki and Shaibu was damaged after the latter insisted on succeeding the governor.
Shaibu was eventually kicked out leading to the emergence of a former chairman of Sterling Bank, Asue Ighodalo as the party’s flag bearer.
The major point of disagreement was the zoning arrangement to ensure equity in the state. Why the incumbent Governor preferred a candidate from Edo Central, Shaibu hails from Edo North.
Shaibu has refused to give up on the battle even after he was impeached by the Edo State House of Assembly and his reinstatement by an Abuja High Court. He seeks a pound of flesh.
He, alongside his supporters, joined forces with the APC and pledged to work with the candidate, Monday Okpebholo in the state to defeat the PDP’s candidate in the election.
Shaibu has also teamed up with party’s national vice chairman (South-South) Dan Orbih, past member of representing Oredo federal constituency, Omorgie Ogbeide-Ihama among others to pledge their support toward Okpebholo’s gubernatorial bid and even donating financially in that regard. They have also collapsed their structures into his campaign team.
Orbih has severally rejected overtures from the PDP to join the Ighodalo’s campaign team in the state.
The decision of the three notable politicians to join forces with the opposition has not gone down well with the PDP in the state, which moved swiftly recently to suspend them, citing anti-party activities.
The party said it suspended Shaibu, Ogbeide-Ihama and Orbih, and that they were no longer needed in Edo PDP.
The suspension of the three top politicians comes amid recent defection of some chieftains and members of Edo PDP to opposition parties.
Recently, Felix Akhabue, one of the governorship aspirants on the PDP, and Frank Okiye, the former Speaker of the Edo State House of Assembly, defected to the APC.
While Akhabue was a former Esan West local government chairman as well as a former Commissioner for Business, Wealth Creation and Cooperative during Governor Obaseki’s first tenure, Okiye was once deputy chief of staff in the office of the deputy governor during the Adams Oshiomhole administration.
Akhabue was one of the 10 aspirants on the platform of PDP for the September 21 governorship election who protested the outcome of the ward and local government congresses.
He was also the Speaker of the Edo State House of Assembly in 2019 but impeached in 2020.
The duo joined several others who defected to APC at a political rally held in Ekpoma, the administrative headquarters of Esan West Local Government Area last month.
Okiye had hinged his decision to resign from the party on the alleged alienation of the majority of his constituents and supporters by the state government from the activities and programmes of the party and the government of the state.
Also, in April, a two-time senator representing Edo South, Matthew Uroghide and several other party members dumped the PDP and switched allegiance to the APC.
Although opinions are divided among party members and observers about the gale of defections and internal crisis in the Edo PDP, many people are surprised that the PDP has not been able to put its house in order since after the primary election.
Across the state, there are growing concerns and anxiety among party members over the likely implication for the party in the September poll.
Some political analysts are of the opinion that the internal crisis in Edo PDP may linger till the gubernatorial election if Governor Obaseki did not make serious efforts to resolve contentious issues.
They also said that the current divided house could have serious implications for the party’s chances, despite being the ruling party in the state.
Others blamed the inability of the Edo PDP to resolve its internal dispute on the fragile state of the party at the national level. They have also advised Obaseki to learn from the Osun State episode, where internal crisis led to the defeat of the APC and its candidate, Gboyega Oyetola by the PDP’s candidate, Ademola Adeleke.
“I think the governor is having an overbearing influence on the party; maybe, he is trying to have control, but you should understand where all this is coming from; it is to install his anointed successor and some people don’t want that, ” a political analyst, Kunle Okunade said.
“At the other end there is the problem of Wike and his group, who would oppose anything Obaseki does; you know Orbih is Wike’s boy. So, it is the problem that we are seeing at the national level that is coming down to Edo. Who controls the party? I wonder who is going to settle, because the party is not even settled at the national level,” he further said.
“I think the election would be decided by who can get votes from other constituencies, particularly Edo South, which has over 60 percent of the votes. But Obaseki has not done badly; maybe, he is not getting the media attention he deserves.
“In the area of insecurity, Edo State is ravaged by insecurity that has undermined the once enterprising people’s effort at self-sufficiency in food production. Equally absent is the formula to tackle youth unemployment in the state”
“But don’t forget that the PDP is the ruling party in Edo, if the party can put its house in order, it has a bright chance of winning,” Femi Lawal, political analyst said.
Sylvester Odion Akhaine, a political scientist, who was an aspirant for the APC ticket, said that both the PDP and APC candidates have the possibility of emerging victorious if they put their houses in order and do the right thing.
“Both the PDP and APC candidates have the possibility of emerging, but APC needs to do a lot of work to consolidate the work of our candidate.
“The way things are it is too early to say, it is too close to call; Okpebholo and Ighodalo would divide Isan votes, Olumide Akpata would probably have a block vote especially the Obidient members in Edo South,” he said.
Akhaine lamented the lack of a clear-cut governance issues and the means to addressing them in the run up to the September 21 gubernatorial election in the state.
He alleged that the state had been led by a self-serving crop of leaders, who were partly imposed, and feeding fat on the commonwealth, while the governance output has been below average, to the detriment of the wellbeing of Edo people.
“In the area of insecurity, Edo State is ravaged by insecurity that has undermined the once enterprising people’s effort at self-sufficiency in food production. Equally absent is the formula to tackle youth unemployment in the state.
“No one has articulated a clear roadmap to deal with these problems. Beyond campaign rhetoric, Edo realities are one of minimal governance and zero in some sectors. In comparative and relative terms, the state cannot rank as a leader in any notable sector of socioeconomic activities.
“Whoever wishes to govern the state must pre-occupy him/her with the issues outlined above and explain them clearly to our people, including how resources will be mobilised to solve the problems beyond the monthly allocation from the central pool.”
However, a legal practitioner, Kalu Agu has predicted landslide victory for the PDP candidate.
Agu explained that disputes which arose from the PDP adhoc delegate congress are internal affairs of the party which are not justiciable under the laws of Nigeria and by the pronouncement of the Supreme Court.
He said from all indications, the people of Edo State have cast their lot with the PDP due to the overwhelming achievements of the Governor Godwin Obaseki-led PDP government.
The election expert stated that his position was a product of a careful and credible study as well as field analysis of the people of Edo State who have tasted what true governance and service delivery is under the current administration.
Agu said, “From all analyses, the people of Edo State are supporting PDP heavily. The PDP is doing very well in Edo State under Governor Obaseki especially because of the numerous developmental projects of the governor.
“All the PDP needs to do now is to come together and consolidate its support. Once they are united, the PDP will take the APC to the cleaners in the forthcoming election.
“Nobody wants to risk having the APC in Edo State. What is happening in Nigeria today under the leadership of the APC is a clear signal that Nigerians across the country have rejected the APC.”
